In this video, we’ll examine the differences between the xTool S1 and the WeCreat Vision.
We’ll be comparing the differences in bed sizes, differences in depth, autofocus systems, the types of laser cutting beds, fire detection systems, changeable laser modules, positioning systems, and we’ll also be placing the lasers head-to-head in multiple tests!
See my other Blog Posts:
Knife Making with the xTool S1
Engrave Metals with the 2watt IR Module for the xTool S1
WeCreat Vision Reviewed
The difference in laser bed sizes:
xTool S1: 19.6”x13” (498x330 mm)
WeCreat Vision: 16.54”x11.42” (420x290mm)
Difference in depth:
xTool S1: 1.7” (42mm)
WeCreat Vision: 5.51” (140mm)
Note that there is a riser addon for the S1 which will increase its depth to 5.3” (133.5mm)
Autofocus systems:
The xTool S1 uses a snappy mechanic probe autofocus. While the WeCreat Vision relies on a slower optical focus system.
I found the autofocus on both laser machines accurate and reliable.
Laser cutting beds
The S1 uses a standard removable honeycomb laser bed and it comes with magnetic hold down clips.
Meanwhile, the Vision used a removable knife bed style.
Fire detection and Fire extinguishing
The xTool S1 has flame detection built in that will turn the machine off if it senses a fire. There is also a fire extinguishing accessory that can be added to the machine.
The WeCreat Vision offers no fire detection at this time.
Interchangeable Laser modules
The xTool S1 offers a 2W IR module for engraving metals and they also offer their regular laser modules in 10w, 20w and 40watts.
WeCreat only offers a 2watt Infrared module for their machines, although they do offer their machines in both 20w and 40w configurations.
Curved Surfaces
The xTool S1 has the ability to laser engrave on curved surfaces.
The Vision does not have curved surface abilities.
Laser Positioning
The S1 uses its “Pin-Point” position system to accurately position objects for lasering.
While the Vision uses a Camera mounted on the lid of the machine.
The Pin-Point position is very accurate but takes time to set up. In contrast, the Visions camera system is quick and easy to use but loses some accuracy.
Laser Engraving Tests on Baltic Birch Plywood (xTool S1 on the Left and WeCreat Vision on the Right):
Laser Engraving Tests on Painted Tiles (xTool S1 on the Left and WeCreat Vision on the Right):
Get the xTool S1 HERE
Get the WeCreat Vision HERE
